Skip to content

Gettysburg Chronicles

History Explained

  • Home
  • Gettysburg
    • History of Adams County
    • Samuel Gettys
    • Call to Arms
    • Days Before The Battle
  • Tales of War
    • Photographs
    • July 5th: Tillie Pierce Tale
    • 57th Pa.: Letter to Mother
    • 24th Mich.: Abel Peck
    • 24th Mich.: Charles Bellore
    • 1st Rifles: Colonel Taylor
    • 7th Mich.: Allen Zacharias
    • 1st Mich.: Amos Ladd
  • Monuments & Artillery
    • First Shot Marker
    • Artillery
      • Different Ammunition
      • Real vs. Fake Cannons
      • Six Pound Shot Cannon
      • Cannons at Devil’s Den
      • Rochester Union Grays
      • Fallen Rochester Grays
    • Michigan
      • 24th Joins Iron Brigade
        • 24th Before Fredericksburg
        • 24th Mich. to Gettysburg
        • 24th Michigan – July 1st
        • 24th Michigan Losses
      • 1st Michigan Infantry
        • 1st Michigan Arrives
        • Michigan Pulls Back
        • First Michigan
      • 3rd Michigan
        • Lost soldiers of the 3rd
      • 4th Michigan
        • Harrison Jeffords
        • Defending the Flag
        • Lost Wolverines
      • Michigan Cavalry
      • Farnsworth’s Cavalry
      • 9th Michigan Battery
      • 7th Michigan Infantry
    • Confederate
      • South Carolina
      • Mississippi Monuments
      • Florida’s Involvement
      • Spirit of Alabama
      • Louisiana Secedes
      • Lonestar State
      • North Carolina
      • Virginia Secedes
      • Arkansas
      • Tennessee – Last to Join
      • Maryland – Border State
      • Georgia – The Peach State
  • Lost Commanders
    • Abraham Lincoln
      • Lincoln Visits Antietam
      • Emancipation Proclamation
      • November 1863
      • Gettysburg Address
      • John Wilkes Booth
      • The Kidnapping Plan
      • Ford’s Theatre
      • Death of Abraham Lincoln
      • Death of an Actor
      • Tribunal Results
    • Stonewall Jackson
      • Spring of 1862
      • Fall of 1862
      • Winter of 1862
      • Family
      • Life After Stonewall
      • Descendants of Jackson
      • Stonewall’s Grandson Tree
    • John F. Reynolds
      • California Love
      • Reynolds Arrives
      • Morning of July 1st
      • July 1st to July 3rd
      • Ms. Mary “Kate” Hewitt
      • Daughters of Charity
  • Railroads
    • Lincoln’s Train Station
    • G&H Railroad
    • Western Maryland Railroad
    • Location of the Spur
    • Gettysburg Electric Trolley
    • Trolley South of Town
    • Railroad to Round-Tops
  • Anniversaries
    • Battlefield Walks
    • 150th Anniversary – 2013
    • 152nd Anniversary – 2015
    • 157th Anniversary – 2020
    • 158th Anniversary – 2021
    • 162nd Anniversary – 2025
    • 163rd Anniversary – 2026
    • Scorching Heat – 2026
  • Other Battles
    • Crampton’s Gap, Md.
    • Fox’s Gap, Md.
    • Turner’s Gap, Md.
    • Andersonville, Ga.
    • Navy – Hampton Roads, Va.
  • Families
    • Wade’s Lineage
      • Thaddeus Filby
      • Rise of the Captain
      • Trouble with the Law
      • Jennie Wade
      • Newspaper Articles
      • Gravesites of Jennie Wade
      • Samuel and Harry Wade
      • James John “Jack” Wade
    • Georgeanna McClellan
      • Extended McClellan’s
      • Iowa Family – Lewis
      • World War II POW
      • Jennie Wade McClellan
      • Nellie McClellan
      • John McClellan
    • Jim B. McClellan
      • Georgia W. McClellan
      • Dallas Schwarzenbach
      • Schwarzenbach’s Children
      • Donald Schwarzenbach
      • Nellie Glady McClellan
      • Mary Wade McClellan
      • Martha McClellan and Children
      • Sarah Isobel Holland
      • Glady Elizabeth Holland
      • Beese Everyln McClellan
      • Sons of Jim Britton
      • Military Ancestors
    • Thorn’s Lineage
      • Evergreen Cemetery: August 1862 to June 1863
      • Gettysburg: June 26, 1863
      • Evergreen Gatehouse
      • Thorn’s Family Tree
      • Descendants of the Thorns
      • Aftermath of Battle
      • Thorn Important Locations
    • Pierce Lineage
      • McCurdy to Pierce Tree
      • James Shaw Pierce
      • William H. Pierce
      • Tillie Pierce
        • Last Week of June 1863
        • Tillie’s Accounts – July 1st
        • Wounded Everywhere
        • Hospital – Pierce House
        • Alleman’s Family
    • Garlach’s Lineage
      • Soldier Hiding with Pigs
      • Anna Garlach
    • Shriver’s Lineage
      • Weikert’s Connection
      • Union Calvary Disaster
      • Father’s Death
      • Henrietta’s New Life
    • Leister’s Lineage
      • Lydia Study Leister
      • July 1st – Lydia’s Home
      • Leister’s House
    • Dobbin’s Lineage
      • Dobbin’s Owns House
      • Miller’s Legacy
      • Brother vs. Brother
      • Snyder’s Legacy
  • Buildings
    • Cashtown
      • July 1863 in Cashtown
      • Cashtown: Since 1863
    • Soldier’s Orphanage
      • Brickyard Fight
      • 154th New York
      • Amos Humiston
      • Rosa Carmichael
    • Houses of the Wades
    • Field Hospitals
      • St. Francis Xavier Church
      • St. James Lutheran Church
    • The House on the Hill
      • Louisiana Tigers
    • Sach’s Bridge
    • Weikert Family Farms
    • Welty House
    • Farnsworth House
    • Winebrenner History
  • Paranormal
    • Paranormal Equipment
    • Spirits at the Cashtown Inn
    • Pictures on the Bridge
    • Live: Sachs Covered Bridge
    • Haunted Orphanage
    • McClellan’s Duplex Kitchen
    • Spirits at the Farnsworth
    • Spirits at Tillie Pierce Inn
  • Questions
  • Toggle search form

Brother vs. Brother

During the Civil War, some families had soldiers on either side of the battlefield. Whether if it was son, father, uncle, cousin, nephew, or a friend, soldiers glared onto the battlefield hoping that their fellow was not across the field of battle waiting for them. However, some families had it worse. In the Dobbin’s family, it was brother versus brother.

Courtesy of Find a Grave –
General Thomas Craig Miller

The third son of General Thomas Craig Miller was Thomas Craig Miller III (1827-1905) and he was a Union War soldier. He was promoted to Captain of the 7th Cavalry, Company F of the Missouri Volunteers. After the war, Capt. Miller III was in command of the guards that laid in state at Washington D.C. after President Lincoln was assassinated.

Courtesy of Find a Grave –
Captain Thomas Craig Miller III

The fourth and last son of General Miller was Captain Matthew Amos Miller. His path towards the Confederacy was odd though. Matthew Amos Miller was born at the Dobbin’s House in 1830. He attended Pennsylvania College (Gettysburg College) from 1847-1850 and studied Civil Engineering, but he didn’t graduate. He then moved to western Virginia and western Maryland, and married Matilda Ann Fechtig in December 1855. He was able to obtain work on the railroads in West Virginia, western Pennsylvania, Maryland, Tennessee, and Mississippi. When the Civil War started in 1861, he was promoted to 4th Confederate Engineers, Company B, and became a Confederate soldier.

Courtesy of Find a Grave –
Captain Matthew Amos Miller

The weird thing hasn’t happened yet though. Capt. Matthew Miller was captured and was sentenced to death by hanging. He was in his cell, and Union General Sherman came to his cell and talked with him. Matthew explained to Sherman that his daughter was “sick”, and wanted to see her before his death. General Sherman granted his request under guard though. When Matthew was home, he escaped and lived until 1904 with his family.

The odd thing wasn’t told yet. The day after his “planned” death was to occur, President Abraham Lincoln pardoned him for the remainder of his life. Lincoln also granted pardons to various Confederate soldiers and officials. Throughout his presidency, he issued 64 pardons for war-related offenses, including treason and rebellion.

@ 2026 Gettysburg Chronicles

Powered by PressBook WordPress theme